P3
Given Title: Pseudo-Rabanus super Porphyrium (P3) (Iwakuma)
Mss
- O: Oxford, Bodleian Libr., Laud. lat. 67, fols 9ra-14vb (ends commenting on Isagoge p. 29.13: Et differentia quidem)
- P: Paris, Bibl. Nationale, lat. 13368, fols 215ra-223vb (ends commenting on Isagoge p. 28.14: Sive enim)
- A: Assisi, Bibl. Comunale, 573, fols 4ra-15vb (complete)
- S: Sankt Gallen, Stiftsbibl.,134, pp. 77a-96a (complete)
- D (= P15):
Dublin, Trinity Col., 494 (E.5.7), fols 113r-118v (excerpts)
Titulus: Rabanus super Por. (P fol. 215ra)
Inc.: Intentio Porphyrii est in hoc opere facilem intellectum ad praedicamenta Aristoteles praeparare, ...
Exp.: ... Sunt supradictoruma aliae communitates et differentiae, sed istae sufficiunt. (AS)
Ed.: Iwakuma 2008 (based only on O, P, A, and D)
Literature
- Cousin 1836, pp. xvii, lxviii-ix, 613-616 (extracts)
- Hauréau 1850 I p. 109 n. 1 = 1872 I p. 145 n. 2
- Cousin 1855 pp. 18, 84-88, 245-249 (extracts)
- Prantl 1885 II pp. 37-40
- Reiners 1907
- Reiners 1910
- Luscombe 1962 p. 219
- De Rijk 1957 I p. 45, II-1 p. 80
- Lohr 1972 p. 383
- Iwakuma 1992 p. 42 n. 22, pp. 43-44 (excerpt)
- Marenbon 1997 p. 31, 34
- Marenbon 1997 pp. 110, 125, 128, 130
- Iwakuma 1996 pp. 12-122, 129-130 (brief extracts)
- Iwakuma 1999 pp. 99-101, 118-122 (extracts)
Comments
The most original version is preserved in O (unfortunately incomplete).
The P-version makes many revisions and additions.
The A-version makes many additions independent from P.
The original version of P3 forms a set with those of C8, H11, and a lost commentary on the De dif. top. from which B10 (a collection of excerpts) was composed. They all are probably written by William of Champeaux. (Iwakuma 1999)
The A-version of P3 forms a set with C14 and H19 (all copied by the same hand in the same ms). (Iwakuma 1999).
Needed to be revised, because of the discovery of a new ms (S) in 2009!!!